The Keefe Report: Proven—The FN America 509 Pistol

by
posted on April 18, 2017
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **

Despite Internet rumors that FN America had submitted the FN Five-SeveN pistol for the Modular Handgun System (MHS) trial to be become the next U.S. service pistol, the gun actually put forward by FN was a 9 mm Luger. And that gun, tested to the tune of 1 million rounds, is now available as the FN 509

FN America has made handguns and its Columbia, S.C., facility since 2001—this is the same plant that makes M4s, M16s, M249s and M240s for the U.S. military. And one of my favorite pistols of the modern era is an FNP-9 in 9 mm Luger. But this is an old-school double-action/single-action gun with an external hammer. It seems the world is not interested in such things anymore.

Last year we did a story on the striker-fired FNS Compact, and it is from that gun that the 509 is derived. But there are plenty of changes to the gun, especially in the ergonomic touches on the grip frame, slimming down here and there and an outstanding new trigger. I had the opportunity to take the 509 down to our range and fire a few magazines through it. Needless to say, I was impressed.

The FNS Compacts will not be discontinued, but will be offered side-by-side with the 509. Think of this gun like the Springfield XD and the upgraded Springfield XD(M). The 509 is priced a little higher than the FNS, and consumer will decide if the upgrade is worth it.

Look for a full report on the FN 509 in the July issue of American Rifleman. Associate Editor Kelly Young shot it extensively, and the cold-hammer-forged barrel on the test gun really delivered in the accuracy department. I have always believed that FN's American-made pistols should garner more attention than they do from consumers. It is my hope that the 509 will make people take a close look at modern FN pistols.

 

Latest

magazines with ammo
magazines with ammo

Old (Un)reliable: Finding a Magazine that Works for Your 1911

There have been more than 100 manufacturers of 1911-style pistols and magazines, some more faithful to the original drawings than others.

3 New Shotgun Suppressors for 2026

Just because you're in the field hunting for upland game or busting clays at your local range doesn't mean you can't protect your hearing.

First Breach Begins Trading on NASDAQ Under "FBDT" Ticker Symbol

In August 2026, First Breach Defense Technologies, a producer of ammunition and unmanned aerial systems based in Hagerstown, Md., announced that its common stock had begun trading on the NASDAQ capital market under the ticker symbol "FBDT."

Review: Franchi Momentum Elite MULE

Franchi’s Momentum Elite MULE is a not-quite-a-scout rifle that has a lot to offer the modern rifle shooter.

The Armed Citizen® Aug. 24, 2026

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

I Have This Old Gun: Smith & Wesson K-22 Masterpiece

Smith & Wesson's rimfire K-22 Masterpiece revolver proved that quality costs, but it also sells.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.