I Have This Old Gun: U.S. Model 1855 Pistol Carbine

by
posted on April 10, 2024

In the 1850s, the United States Ordnance Dept. began taking steps to modernize its inventory of small arms, examining early breechloading designs and improving its standard-issue rifle musket. One of the new arms introduced to service was the Model 1855 Pistol Carbine, designed to pull double-duty as a shoulder arm and a pistol. Watch our "American Rifleman Television" I Have This Old Gun segment above to see how this design really didn't perform as expected.

"Even well into the 1850s, the U.S. Ordnance Dept. is generally a conservative outfit, but they do take a step forward just immediately before the Civil War with the Model 1855 rifle musket, which uses the Maynard tape primer system," said American Rifleman Executive Editor Evan Brune. "And then also the Model 1855 Pistol Carbine, which also uses the Maynard tape primer system. And while the Model 1855 rifle musket was largely a very useful platform that saw extensive service during the Civil War, the 1855 Pistol Carbine was a concept that really was, in large part, a swing and a miss."

Model 1855 pistol carbine laying on a cavalryman's blue jacket next to a paper cartridge and a roll of Maynard tape primers.

As a pistol, the design had a 12" long barrel and measured 17" in overall length, making it somewhat cumbersome and unwieldy. As a carbine, once the attached shoulder stock was mated to the pistol, the design immediately became too short to be as effective as some other cavalry carbines being fielded at the time, as the short barrel reduced muzzle velocity and the shortened sight radius made it harder to use effectively at longer ranges.

"As a pistol coming out in 1855, it was already well behind the power curve of Colt's revolvers that were the mainstay of the marketplace at that point. Why have a single-shot muzzleloader when you can have a six-shot revolver in your hand?" said Philip Schreier, director of the National Firearms Museum. "As far as a carbine is concerned, you know, putting the shoulder stock on it, evidently, they never really tightened down that well. They were wobbly, which led to inaccuracy. And they couldn't really compete when you had something like a Sharps."

Man detaching the shoulder stock from the U.S. Model 1855 pistol carbine.

Despite the shortcomings of the platform, one mechanical advancement incorporated into the Model 1855 Pistol Carbine was the Maynard tape priming system. Designed by Edward Maynard, a dentist by trade, the system used a roll of priming compound held inside a small cavity inside the lockplate of a compatible firearm. A geared wheel advanced the priming compound up onto the nipple once the hammer was cocked.

"It's ingenious, and under the proper circumstances it worked just fine," said American Rifleman Field Editor Garry James. "The problem is, in cold weather they became brittle, and in hot weather, they became gummy and sticky. Hence, the tape priming system, for all its cleverness, all its ingenuity, was really not used all that much. Fortunately, the nipple could also handle the normal top wing percussion cap, which they later used."

Man aiming the U.S. Model 1855 pistol carbine without a shoulder stock attached against a green, outdoors background.

Even though the Model 1855 Pistol Carbine wasn't ideal for field use, the desperate shortage of arms at the beginning of the Civil War meant that these guns were issued to Western troops in the quieter parts of the country as the war raged in the south and east.

"There were better mousetraps, and the 1855 was not the better mousetrap," NRA Publications Editorial Director Mark Keefe said. "As a matter of fact, Confederate Gen. Ewell basically said these are not suitable for dragoon use. And dragoons were basically mounted infantrymen."

To watch complete segments of past episodes of American Rifleman TV, go to americanrifleman.org/artv. For all-new episodes of ARTV, tune in Wednesday nights to Outdoor Channel 8:30 p.m. and 11:30 p.m. EST.

Latest

British Pattern 1801 Sea Service Pistol held in hand outdoors shooting firing blackpowder muzzleloading
British Pattern 1801 Sea Service Pistol held in hand outdoors shooting firing blackpowder muzzleloading

I Have This Old Gun: British Pattern 1801 Sea Service Pistol

One of the mainstays in the British Royal Naval arsenal of small arms was the Pattern 1801 Sea Service Pistol, a design that equipped sailors for ship-to-ship fighting.

New For 2025: Hi-Point Large Format Pistols

Hi-Point Firearms expanded its handgun lineup with large-format pistol variants of its popular pistol-caliber carbines.

SAAMI Conference Reflects Growing Industry Dedication To Innovation

“This year’s record attendance is a clear indication of the importance of this event to the ammunition and firearm development and testing community, as well as government and law enforcement test labs and procurement activities,” said Joe Bartozzi, SAAMI president and CEO.

Favorite Firearms: Outstanding Customer Service!

I purchased my first pistol, a .32-cal. Walther PPK in 1969. Why choose a .32 ACP and not a more powerful .380 ACP? Because .32 was the chambering that Ian Fleming’s fictional character James Bond switched to when Q forced him to give up his beloved .25-cal. Beretta.

 

Preview: N8 Tactical Mini Xecutive

The Mini Xecutive from N8 Tactical is an inside-the-waistband holster intended to be carried in the appendix position.

A Pair Of Fiesty Felines: The 80X Cheetah And 30X Tomcat Get Home Bag

Few manufacturers have embraced the mouse-gun concept as thoroughly as Beretta—and proof is in the updates to its two smallest pistol lines.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.