Fear & Loading: Legal Battle Between Big Gunmakers

by
posted on October 18, 2018
sig_glock.png

Last week attorneys for SIG Sauer and Glock met with three judges in Austria and began formally arguing a lawsuit filed in January that claims the latter’s Gen. 5 and 19X handguns infringe on a SIG Sauer breechblock patent. The complaint asks, among other things, that all pistols in violation be destroyed and that production of firearms employing the design cease immediately. SIG Sauer’s request for a preliminary injunction was rejected in July.

“The obligation to cease and desist, in particular, would have a massive impact on Glock, because some of the most successful models couldn’t be sold anymore,” Glock said in its report to the panel, according to Business Day.

Tense relations between the legendary gunmakers is not new. Both companies submitted sidearms for the U.S. Army’s lucrative Modular Handgun System competition, but a version of the SIG P320 was announced the winner in early 2017. Glock immediately filed a protest with the Government Accounting Office, although it was denied.

Each firm has carved a big slice of the law enforcement market. Late last year Blue Line, a Canadian publication for that nation’s law enforcement, put it in perspective with results from its annual Gun Survey. It found 75 percent of the country’s agencies now issue Glocks (compared to 38 percent a decade ago) and that figure is currently stands at 65 percent in the United States. The most popular SIG Sauer handgun with law enforcement in Canada is the P226. Although market share wasn’t reported, there’s no shortage of U.S. agencies adopting the P320 after the military adopted a version of the pistol.

Part of Glock’s response to the Austrian lawsuit claims the design isn’t novel enough from those already being manufactured to qualify for a patent. Hearings have been recessed until the Austrian Patent Office can issue a report.

 

Latest

Bayard Auto Pistol
Bayard Auto Pistol

I Have This Old Gun: Bayard Auto Pistol

The Herstal, Belgium, firm of Anciens Etablissements Pieper was apparently expecting big things when, in 1908, it named its new semi-automatic pocket pistol “Bayard.”

The Armed Citizen® March 31, 2025

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

New For 2025: Benelli USA Nova 3 Tactical

This latest update to Benelli’s pump-action shotgun gives users a few upgrades over previous generations, making the new NOVA 3 the most exciting pump-gun yet to come from the Italian maker.

Mauser: The Rifle That Made Good

Combining inventive genius with shrewd sales ability, the Mauser brothers, Paul and Wilhelm launched one of the world’s most famous small arms dynasties.

Preview: Hornady Backcountry Defense

The company’s new Backcountry Defense line is designed specifically for personal protection in the backcountry.

Military Armament Corporation Introduces New MAC 9 DS Models

Military Armament Corporation expanded its line of M1911-style, double-stack handguns with its new Double-Stack Duty, D-Comp and Comp designs.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.