FBI Underreports Armed Citizen Actions, Study Says

by
posted on October 1, 2023
Man suit tie handgun pistol drawing concealment concealed carry leather holster semi-automatic black pistol

A detailed study on lives saved by the actions of armed, law-abiding citizens, issued on Aug. 31 by the Crime Prevention Research Center (CPRC), found the number reported annually by the FBI reflects a mere fraction of the real figure.

“The FBI reports that armed citizens only stopped 14 of the 302 active shooter incidents it identified for the period 2014-2022,” the report states. “An analysis by the CPRC identified a total of 440 active shooter incidents during that period and found that an armed citizen stopped 157.”

Even back in 1907, when Mark Twain penned his autobiography, the peril of relying on single-source mathematical analysis was painfully obvious. “There are three kinds of lies: Lies, damned lies and statistics,” he wrote, duly noting that Benjamin Disraeli made the timeless observation before him.

Misinformation is a fact of life, but today, it reproduces at Internet speed and can wind up in the algorithms and programs we now rely on—particularly when it comes from an authority like the FBI. It also infects mainstream media, public opinion and, ultimately, fuels political rhetoric and uninformed legislation. The report’s observation that “The FBI’s active shooting reports do not mention whether the attacks occur in gun-free zones,” highlights the latter threat.

“The FBI reported that armed citizens thwarted 4.6 percent of active shooter incidents, while the CPRC found 35.7 percent,” the report states. “In 2022, it is at least 41.3 percent. Excluding gun-free zones, it averaged over 63.5 percent.”

The difference is staggering and stands in stark contrast to what’s portrayed in the media. CPRC notes there are several factors that contribute to the FBI’s underreporting. The Bureau, for example, only includes those that take place in a “populated public place…” and “…does not include those it deems related to other criminal activity, such as a robbery or fighting over drug turf.” Clerical errors and those incidents deemed “miscellaneous” add to the inaccuracy.

It’s likely Twain could find something humorous in the FBI statistics, although it’s doubtful he’d put any of the words on paper. He was an outspoken advocate for fingerprinting—including it prominently in two of his books—long before U.S. law enforcement departments harnessed the technology.

 

Latest

Man author christopher olsen holding in hands outdoors benelli nova 3 tactical pump-action shotgun black gun
Man author christopher olsen holding in hands outdoors benelli nova 3 tactical pump-action shotgun black gun

New For 2025: Benelli USA Nova 3 Tactical

This latest update to Benelli’s pump-action shotgun gives users a few upgrades over previous generations, making the new NOVA 3 the most exciting pump-gun yet to come from the Italian maker.

Mauser: The Rifle That Made Good

Combining inventive genius with shrewd sales ability, the Mauser brothers, Paul and Wilhelm launched one of the world’s most famous small arms dynasties.

Preview: Hornady Backcountry Defense

The company’s new Backcountry Defense line is designed specifically for personal protection in the backcountry.

Military Armament Corporation Introduces New MAC 9 DS Models

Military Armament Corporation expanded its line of M1911-style, double-stack handguns with its new Double-Stack Duty, D-Comp and Comp designs.

Preview: MTM Case-Gard Ruger 10/22 Extended Mag Can

Made in the U.S.A., the O-ring-sealed Mag Can from MTM Case-Gard stows one of the most important parts of the semi-automatic carbine—the magazine—twelve BX-25-pattern extended magazines, to be exact.

Gun Of The Week: EAA Witness2311 Brat

Built on M1911 principles and imported by European American Armory Corp., the EAA Girsan Witnesss2311 Brat is a unique take on the double-stack, 2011-style pistol.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.