The Homogenized Handgun Business

posted on April 22, 2011
ii2015_fs.jpg (1)

With the announcement that Sturm, Ruger & Co. will be introducing an M1911 pistol at the upcoming NRA Annual Meetings in Pittsburgh, the American handgun industry is fully homogenized.

No longer is a Ruger a Ruger, a Colt a Colt, a Smith a Smith, each with unique, proprietary features. In general, many of the products from the big manufacturers are now so indistinguishable that you might as well close your eyes over a gun shop counter, spin in a circle and point. Whatever your finger lands on, you can be assured that it will be pretty much the same gun as the one next to it, albeit with a different logo.

With Ruger’s new SR1911, the venerable .45 ACP pistol, Model Of 1911, is now manufactured by every major manufacturer. Everyone now makes a Glock derivative of some sort or another—an inexpensive, plastic 9 mm. When Kel-Tec dared to do something innovative—a very small, lightweight, plastic .380 ACP pocket pistol—everyone immediately introduced a “me too” model.

Imitation has replaced innovation in the big handgun companies. It used to be that every company had its signature products, guns so trademarked to their maker that they could be spotted across a room. The vent ribbed barrel and royal blue of a Colt Python. The distinctive profile of a Smith & Wesson Model 29, immortalized by Detective Harry Callahan. The Luger-esque shape of a Ruger Mk I .22 LR, easily distinguished from a Colt Woodsman or a S&W Model 41.

The reason for this commoditization of handguns is found in Market Economics 101. A handgun is a mature product in a stable market. It’s not an iPhone 4 with millions of new consumers. It’s a lawnmower. The demand curve flattened out, oh, about 30 years ago. Compared to cell phones, no new technology is forcing consumers to buy a new handgun.

Because the handgun demand curve is so flat, manufacturers can’t grow their sales with break-out new models that prompt new consumers to buy. The only way to grow sales in a flat market is to take market share away from a competitor.

Consider the M1911, the best case in point. The exact number is impossible to know because of the vagaries of ATF data (which is based on caliber, not model type), however, reliable estimates suggest there are between 120,000 and at most 180,000 M1911s sold annually.

If you’re the CEO of Ruger, you look at the M1911 and see a potential to sell X-percent of that number. Without a Government Model, you sell zero into that category; with it, you do.

Who will buy a Ruger SR1911? Someone who is looking for an M1911 anyway but now is attracted to a combination of three things (in order): price, brand, features.

Ruger’s SR1911 is going at with a suggested retail of $799 which is in keeping with Ruger’s value proposition that comes with everything the New Hampshire company makes. How many will they sell? I predict something in the 15,000 range per year, which is 15,000 fewer M1911s that some competitor won’t sell.

Latest

Heckler & Koch USA HK VP9A1 pistol right-side view improved new version shown with ammunition and gear optic safe duty belt boots
Heckler & Koch USA HK VP9A1 pistol right-side view improved new version shown with ammunition and gear optic safe duty belt boots

New For 2025: Heckler & Koch VP9A1

Heckler & Koch has updated its popular VP9 design with the VP9A1, which includes a Universal Ergonomic Grip that even allows for length-of-pull adjustments.

Preview: TOPS Knives El Chete

Despite its 12" blade of 0.250"-thick 1095 steel, the TOPS El Chete comes in at only 29.5 ozs. with a balance and ergonomics that help it make quick work of clearing shooting lanes or building shelters.

Gun Of The Week: Mossberg International Gold Reserve Black

Join American Rifleman staff on the range in this episode to learn about Mossberg’s International Gold Reserve model, the company's self-proclaimed “top-shelf” shotgun featuring an aluminum 20-ga. receiver.

The Armed Citizen® March 14, 2025

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

Triplett & Scott Arms Of Kentucky

Triplett & Scott Arms created a unique breechloading carbine near the end of the Civil War, and before the war's end, 5,000 guns were produced to protect Union Army supply lines in Kentucky.

10 Companies Join SAAMI—Why It’s Good News For Enthusiasts

There’s good reason why more firearm and ammunition manufacturers joining SAAMI, an organization founded in 1926 at the request of the federal government, is good news for gun owners.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.